Changing Behavior Or Changing Hearts

Is your parenting focused more on changing behavior or changing hearts? It’s a tough question but one that Christian parents should answer in their parenting. Behavior can be modified through consequences and teaching, but the heart is something God changes.

So how do we balance these two things in our parenting?

Changing behavior or changing hearts

As God looks at our hearts, he wants us to look at our children’s hearts when making decisions about discipline. Is this an issue of bad behavior or is there a deeper underlying problem that needs to be addressed? If so, what can you do to help that need to be met and help your child grow in Christ?

Author Cary Schmit asks the question this way in his book Passionate Parenting:

If you had to quantify your parenting focus with the following words, which two would be most accurate: Managing Behavior or  Mentoring Hearts?

In the big picture, all discipline is about bringing our children into a right relationship with their Heavenly Father that He might bless their lives. It’s not about controlling behavior, modifying behavior, or minimizing embarrassment. Biblically correcting your child is one of the greatest ways to win their heart to you and to God forever. (Passionate Parenting)

I love his reminder of what the real purpose of discipline is!

However, if we are being truthful we would probably have to admit that often we forget that, and get frustrated when our children show wrong behavior.

It’s easy to look at wrong behavior as a disruption in our day which causes us to stop what we are doing to go and deal with it. That causes us to focus on changing the behavior without any focus on the heart issue.

building a strong foundation

As a result, we focus on trying to get them to change their wrong behavior while failing to address the cause of it or the heart issue.

In the book Parenting Is Heart Work we are reminded that:

God in interested in hearts because that’s where real and lasting change takes place. In fact, when you direct your energies toward your child’s heart, amazing things will happen.

Parents often becomes the hands and feet God uses to mold a child’s heart. Our job is to find out where God is working and then partner with Him to do the deeper work necessary in our kids’ lives.

Rather than viewing wrong behavior as an interruption and getting irritated about it, we need to remember that it is really an awesome opportunity to use God’s Word to address the heart issue causing that behavior.

It is a chance for us to become the hands and feet God uses to mold our child’s heart.

I don’t know about you, but the idea of God using me to mold the hearts of my kids is exciting! As I address the heart issue, I am opening the door for God to work in my child’s heart and life.

The exciting thing is that God gave us His word as the tool we need to bring them into a right relationship with Him.

Using Scripture is one of the most powerful ways to correct and train our children’s hearts, because God’s Word has power that our words don’t have, and His Word brings conviction.


Putting this into practical terms, when your kids are arguing don’t just get aggravated and yell at them to “Stop it right now!’ When handling sibling squabbles deal with the heart issue.

Is it pride or anger, etc? Once you have determined the heart issue, take them to God’s Word and show them what He says about it.

For example, show them verses about how God hates pride, and how pride leads to destruction. Have them memorize one of the verses which they feel will help them in this area. Then pray with them about it, asking God to help them not to have a proud heart.


Training and correcting the heart with Scripture. This book is designed to make it simple for parents to use God's Word for reproof, correction and training in righteousness. CLICK HERE to learn more.

It’s easy to fall into the habit of trying to change behavior because that is easier.

We think that we need to have a strong hand of authority that intimidates our kids into changing that behavior. It also seems more rewarding at the time, because then you have a “well-behaved child.”

However, that “well-behaved child” may not act the same when you aren’t around to control their behavior. Changing behavior really only focuses on the short term.

Correcting or mentoring the heart takes time and training, and the results aren’t immediately visible. However, they last a lifetime.

While some of our parenting needs to focus on correcting behavior, we have to remember that shouldn’t be the gauge for our success, because God looks on the heart. Good behavior can be from a right heart, but it can also be a temporary thing to appease you.

It’s important that you get below the surface of right behavior, and work to build right beliefs from God’s Word in your child’s heart.

As author Cary Schmidt says:  Short-view parenting builds behavior. Long-view parenting builds belief.

Be sure to ask God to help you consistently focus on changing your child’s heart, and building belief as you point them to God’s Word.

Get our free list of 20 Ways To Win Your Child’s Heart!

Changing Behavior Or Changing Hearts


changing behavior or changing hearts

Top Posts

Leave a Reply

  • Homeschool Builders Missouri Homeschool Planner

    Select options
  • Mentor Call with Kathie from the Character Corner

    Mentor Coaching With Kathie | 30-Minute Call

    Add to cart
  • TExt on image reads declutter challenge planning pack

    Declutter Challenge Printable Pack

    Add to cart
  • text on image reads stress free holiday planner

    Stress-Free Holiday Planner: The Tips, List, Calendars and Guides You Need to Get Organized This Holiday Season

    Add to cart
  • HIgh School Character Building Workbook

    High School Character Building Workbook

    Select options
  • high school course of study books

    High School Course of Study & Planning Workbook

    Add to cart
  • Mini Character Building Boot Camp

    Add to cart
  • Image shows Little Lads and Ladies of Virtue COPYWORK book

    Lads & Ladies of Virtue Copywork eBook – Biblical Character Training for Kids

    Add to cart
  • Cover Spiral Building by the Book

    Building By The Book – A Practical Resource for Building Your Family on the Word of God

    Add to cart
  • The Importance of Winning Your Child's Heart The Character Corner

    The Importance of Winning Your Child’s Heart {Updated Edition}

    Select options
  • Spiral Parenting Mistakes That Push Your Child Away The Character Corner

    Parenting Mistakes That Push Your Kids Away

    Select options
  • Valentines Day Coupon book

    Valentine’s Day Coupon Book

    Add to cart
  • Intentional LIving LIfe Management for Busy Moms Course by the Character Corner

    Intentional Living – Life Management For Busy Moms (Online Course)

    Add to cart
  • Spiral Cover Names of Jesus Advent Countdown The Character Corner

    The Names of Jesus Advent Countdown Printables Pack

    Add to cart
  • 30 days of Homeschool Encouragement Cover eBook


    Add to cart